Squeeze the skin between your 3rd and 4th toes — press from top and bottom with your thumb and index finger. Burning or shooting pain? That's the clinical test physical therapists use (96% sensitivity, 96% specificity). If it's positive, your first step today is changing your shoes. TREATMENT: Tier 1 — Wide toe-box footwear + metatarsal pad placed PROXIMAL to the heads (4-6mm, firm material) Tier 1 — US-guided corticosteroid injection (1-2 max, methylprednisolone 40mg, 4-6 week interval) — best for lesions <6.3mm Tier 2 — Alcohol sclerotherapy (4% ethanol, 3-7 injection series, US-guided) — chemical neurolysis Tier 2 — Pain neuroscience education + intrinsic foot loading (BFR → HSR progression) What doesn't work: Pad directly on pain, blind injections, serial CSI on large neuromas (>6.3mm), passive modalities alone
Think of an electrical cable running through a conduit that's slightly too narrow. Every time you take a step, the conduit walls squeeze together. Over months and years, the cable develops scar tissue where it keeps getting pinched. That scar tissue makes the cable thicker, which means the squeeze gets worse with every step. The burning, shooting pain isn't the cable breaking — it's the alarm system saying the pinching is happening again.
A nerve between your foot bones gets squeezed until it scars over — then it hurts with every step
⚑ If any of the above apply: book an urgent appointment with your GP or go to urgent care. Do not start self-treatment.
Conservative management succeeds in 68-80% of cases when properly executed. The most common reason it fails isn't the wrong injection — it's wrong pad placement or continuing to wear the wrong shoes.
Don't use "when it feels better" as the return criteria. Use these checkboxes:
Bilateral lower body compound training (squat, deadlift, hip hinge) continues from Day 1 in appropriate footwear. Running and forefoot plyometrics are held until criteria above are met.
The most common driver of unnecessary surgery is poor-quality conservative care — wrong pad placement, narrow footwear kept in use, unguided injections. Surgery is indicated when conservative management has been correctly executed and genuinely failed (≥4.5-6 months, ≥2 US-guided CSI, neuroma >6.3-8mm confirmed on US). Dorsal and plantar neurectomy have equivalent outcomes — dorsal allows earlier weight-bearing, plantar has lower sensory loss rate (48.5% vs lower for plantar).
1. A parallel-group RCT (N=120) comparing BFR/HSR intrinsic foot strengthening vs custom metatarsal-pad orthoses alone for lesions <5mm at 12 months — to determine whether active loading independently changes outcomes.
2. A double-blind multi-centre RCT (N=200) comparing 3-injection 4% alcohol sclerotherapy series vs single US-guided CSI at >24-month follow-up — to resolve the injection hierarchy beyond 12 months.
3. A prospective cohort study (N=500) tracking neuroma size in 1mm increments across purely conservative management — to definitively establish the natural history failure threshold (currently inferred as 6.3-8mm).
Evidence-scored research on pain, rehab, and performance — direct to your inbox. No fluff, no pop-science.
Join The Verdict — FreeHow strong is the evidence for the claims in this review? Higher = more confidence the claims are supported. This does not measure how large the effect is or how important it is compared with other levers.
Physio conditions reviewed against clinical evidence. What works, what doesn't, and what to do — from a practising physiotherapist.
Subscribe freeThe Verdict is built by the same team behind Precision Metrics — a physique and health coaching practice with 300+ clients coached. Dr. Seth Holbrook, DPT and Luke Holbrook lead the coaching.
Book a free consultationConviction-scored verdicts on supplements, nutrition, training, physio, and recovery.